Intraoperative tissue expansion in rhytidectomy revisited

Intraoperative tissue expansion is an adjunct that has been used during rhytidectomy to rejuvenate the face and neck. This technique has been thought to allow for additional skin resection and, thus, increased skin tightening during rhytidectomy. The stretch of the skin by expansion should allow for additional skin resection before closure. Also, when the force of the underlying expander is removed, the expanded skin would recoil and the advancement of the flap should become tighter, with improved results. The technique achieved some popularity a few years ago but has received little recent attention. In this study, the authors attempted to compare face-lift results of adjunctive intraoperative tissue expansion during rhytidectomy with similar techniques without intraoperative expansion. The results of 50 female patients who underwent rhytidectomy for midface rejuvenation by a single operating surgeon composed the study group. Twenty-five of the patients had undergone rhytidectomy that addressed the cheek, chin, and neck areas without expansion (nonexpanded rhytidectomy group). The other 25 patients (expanded rhytidectomy group) had adjunctive intraoperative tissue expansion performed with the rhytidectomy. A tissue expander was temporarily placed beneath the rhytidectomy flaps on each side and expanded in a standard manner before final skin resection and closure. Frontal and lateral photographs were evaluated by 54 examiners. Preoperative and postoperative photographs of the 50 patients were viewed side-by-side by the examiners. The patients were presented in blind fashion and random order. The examiners graded the results of each patient on a scale of improvement from 1 to 10, with 10 being the maximum level of improvement. The scores were recorded and statistically evaluated by using the two-sample test. Evaluation of the examiners' scores showed that the mean rating given to patients in the expanded rhytidectomy group was 5.07 (SD = 1.12). The mean rating for the nonexpanded rhytidectomy group was 5.27 (SD = 1.57). When the two groups were compared using the two-sample test, the difference between the two was not statistically significant (p = 0.6127). Intraoperative tissue expansion as an adjunct to rhytidectomy did not result in improved facial rejuvenation in this patient series. The authors' impression is that the benefits of tissue expansion do not justify the added expense, time, and risks associated with using tissue expansion during rhytidectomy.