Demineralization of Er:YAG and Er,Cr:YSGG laser-prepared enamel cavities in vitro

The aim of the present study was to establish whether cavity preparation by means of an erbium laser with efficient water cooling is capable of reducing the susceptibility of the prepared dental enamel to demineralization and thus of achieving a potential caries-protective effect in the region of cavity margins. To this end, cavities limited to the enamel were prepared in the crowns of 10 teeth each using an Er:YAG (lambda = 2,940 nm) and an Er,Cr:YSGG laser (lambda = 2,780 nm). A control cavity prepared conventionally with a diamond drill in the same occlusal zone was assigned to each of these cavities. The specimens were then subjected to a pH-cycling caries model. Analysis was performed by quantitatively measuring the demineralization front under a polarized-light microscope. The results of the study showed that enamel cavities prepared with the erbium lasers used display a statistically significant acceleration of demineralization compared to conventionally prepared cavities (p < 0.01). The Er:YAG laser cavities revealed demineralization to a depth of 133.9 (SD 25.7) microm, while the value observed with the Er,Cr:YSGG laser was 133.8 (SD 25.8) microm. The depth of demineralization in the control groups was only 77.4 (SD 13.8) microm and 79.3 (SD 37.6) microm. No difference could be found between the two lasers (p = 0.98). Based on these in vitro tests, it cannot be assumed that use of the erbium laser for cavity preparation offers any advantages in terms of resistance to secondary caries in clinical practice.