Questionnaire reveals variations in the management of acute first time shoulder dislocations in the Netherlands

To collect information about the management of patients with acute first time shoulder dislocation by (orthopaedic) surgeons in the accident and emergency departments of Dutch hospitals.

Questionnaires were sent to 131 (orthopaedic) surgeons of 74 Dutch hospitals.

We enquired whether patients with acute first time shoulder dislocation are managed according to protocols in accident and emergency departments; which radiographs are deemed necessary before and after reduction; which reduction methods are generally performed; and what kind of pain relief or sedatives are generally administered. Furthermore, we enquired into the method and duration of immobilization after reduction.

The response rate was 73%. Sixty-five per cent of the hospitals are used to managing acute first time shoulder dislocation according to protocols. Making prereduction and postreduction radiographs is standard practice in almost all hospitals. The most favoured methods of reduction are those according to Kocher and Hippocrates. In 85% of cases sedatives are administered before reduction, and in addition to that systemic analgesia is administered in 30%, whereas intra-articular analgesia is preferred in 25% of cases.

Apparently, a protocol for the management of acute first time shoulder dislocation is not standardly available in all hospitals. On the basis of current literature and the results of this questionnaire it may be useful to establish a guideline for diagnostic procedures and the management of acute first time shoulder dislocation in accident and emergency departments.