Management of gallstone disease in the elderly

To determine the outcome of management of symptomatic gallstone disease (GSD) in patients aged 80 years or more.

A retrospective review of the outcome of 79 patients admitted to 2 district general hospitals with symptomatic GSD over a 1-year period was undertaken. Patients were grouped according to method of management: non-operative, ERCP, and cholecystectomy. POSSUM scores for the ERCP and cholecystectomy groups were calculated and observed, and predicted outcome compared.

Obstructive jaundice and biliary colic were the most common presenting symptoms. Each patient had been admitted at least once before the study period (median, 2; range, 1-3). Outcomes are detailed in Table 1. Non-operative management failed in 18 of 23 patients, with 17.4% mortality. ERCP was successful in 40 of 47 patients with 3 complications (0.24 of predicted) and no mortality. In all, 11 laparoscopic and 12 open cholecystectomies were performed with 6 complications and 1 mortality (0.95 and 0.83 of predicted, respectively): 4 complications and the only death occurring after emergency cholecystectomy. Table 1 Outcomes Management Number Mortality Morbidity Outcome Non-operative 23 4 9 5 OK, 13 re-admitted, 4 still symptomatic ERCP 47 0 3 1 PTC, 6 operated Operative 23 1 6 CONCLUSIONS: This study suggests that recurrent GSD in elderly patients managed non-operatively may have fatal outcome. Elective cholecystectomy has acceptable morbidity and mortality in this age group and there is often ample opportunity to avoid emergency surgery, but a prospective randomised study is required to improve clinical algorithms.