Alpha-methylacyl-CoA racemase (P504S) expression in evolving carcinomas within benign prostatic hyperplasia and in...

Carcinomas of the transition zone (TZ) constitute approximately 20% of all prostate cancers. The TZ is the site of origin of grade 1 and grade 2 cancers, the most well-differentiated of the Gleason grade tumors, as well as for benign prostatic hyperplasia (BPH). In this regard, grade 1 carcinoma has architectural features that closely mimic gland-rich BPH nodules. Although a relationship between cancers arising in this zone and BPH has been suspected, such an association remains undefined. To gain insight into the origin, development, and progression of cancers arising in the TZ, we used a highly specific rabbit monoclonal antibody (P504S) directed against alpha-methylacyl-CoA racemase (AMACR) to study the expression of the enzyme in 25 cases of evolving and fully developed carcinomas of this zone. AMACR has been proposed as a new molecular marker for prostate cancer, because the enzyme is reportedly overexpressed in high-grade dysplasias, also termed prostatic intraepithelial neoplasia, a purported precursor of prostatic carcinoma, and in all grades of prostatic carcinoma of the peripheral zone. Using P504S, P63, or antikeratin 34beta E12 antibodies, we found it possible to define areas of transition from hyperplasia to carcinoma in 6 BPH nodules. In 3 other cancer-containing BPH nodules, staining for AMCAR was observed in benign hyperplastic glands that were juxtaposed to carcinoma. Enzyme expression was also evident in 5 additional cases in which BPH was found adjacent to cancer. In contrast; AMACR was not visualized in any other BPH nodules that we studied. Thus, using the enzyme as a marker, we document for the first time that some carcinomas of the TZ arise from an AMCAR-positive transition lesion within a subset of BPH nodules. Moreover, the finding of enhanced AMACR expression in benign glands within cancer-containing nodules as well as in BPH lesions adjacent to carcinoma suggests that in some cases, up-regulation of the enzyme may precede morphological evidence of neoplastic transformation. AMACR was lightly expressed in transition lesions and grade 1 carcinomas but more strongly expressed in higher-grade TZ cancers, suggesting that enzyme expression is enhanced with progression in this zone. Because AMACR is involved in the beta oxidation of branched fatty acids and their derivatives, enhanced expression of the enzyme in evolving carcinomas in BPH nodules, as well as its up-regulation in juxtaposed morphologically benign glands and grade 1 carcinomas, suggests that increased utilization of fatty acids may play an important role in carcinoma development and progression in the TZ.