Management of recurrent inguinal hernias: a prospective study of 163 cases

There remains debate as to how recurrent inguinal hernias should be managed. This study aimed to establish a management plan for recurrent hernias. From 1991-2000, 163 patients were operated on for recurrent inguinal hernias. The average interval from the initial surgery to recurrence was 46 months (range 10 days-13 years). The initial surgery prior to recurrence was Shouldice and other techniques without mesh in 142 cases, a Stoppa or a Lichtenstein procedure in ten and three cases, respectively, and laparoscopic repair in eight cases. The recurrent hernias were treated with a Shouldice repair in 52 cases (31.9%), the Lichtenstein technique in 48 cases (29.4%), a totally extraperitoneal laparoscopic repair in 40 cases (24.5%), and a Stoppa procedure in 23 (14.1%). The approaches to management evolved with time: the use of prostheses for recurrent hernia repair increased from 10% in 1991 (2/10) to 100% in 2000 (22/22). In contrast, the Shouldice repair decreased from 90% (18/20) in 1991 to 0% (0/22) in 2000. The Lichtenstein technique was first employed in 1993, in patients with a history of a conventional, laparoscopic, or Stoppa repair and has increased to represent 77% of cases (17/22) in 2000. The Stoppa technique has not been used since 1998. The use of a totally extraperitoneal laparoscopic approach went from 11% (2/18) in 1992 (introduction of the technique) to 23% (5/22) in 2000 and is reserved for recurrence after a Lichtenstein procedure or after conventional repair in working and/or physically active patients without any contraindications to general anesthesia. Prosthetic reinforcement has become the norm in the treatment of recurrent hernias. Given a previous conventional repair, the prosthesis can be placed by either an anterior or posterior approach. The approach is dependent on the level of activity and operability of the patient. If the recurrence follows a totally extraperitoneal or a Stoppa procedure, then the Lichtenstein intervention is recommended. A recurrence after a Lichtenstein procedure should be treated by a totally extraperitoneal approach.