Rectal excision with coloanal anastomosis for superficial distal third rectal cancer: survival and local recurrence

Appropriate surgical treatment of distal third rectal cancer limited to bowel wall (i.e. T1 or T2) in medically operable patients is controversial. Transanal excision can deprive some patients of accurate pathological staging, prognosis and cure. In contrast abdominoperineal resection has considerable practical and psychosocial problems largely related to a permanent colostomy. We hypothesize that superficial distal rectal tumours can be effectively treated with rectal excision and coloanal anastomosis.

Prospective oncological study of 80 patients with distal third superficial rectal carcinomas treated by complete rectal excision with coloananl anastomosis from December 1977 to January 1993 was carried out. The resected specimens were examined for depth of spread and number of histologically positive nodes. The actuarial local recurrence and survival rates for superficial node-negative and node-positive tumours were analysed independently.

Seventy-eight patients had complete postoperative assessment. Thirty-one percent had received low-dose preoperative neo-adjuvant radiotherapy (3500 rads). Mean follow-up time in all patients was 70 months on average. The lymph node involvement rate for T1 and T2 tumours was 12.5 and 15.6%, respectively. The local recurrence rates for patients with (T1/T2) N0 and (T1/T2) N1 were 1.5 and 16.7%, respectively, and the five year actuarial survival rates were 96.6 and 90%, respectively. The overall local recurrence was 3.8% with five-year actuarial survival of 95.8%.

Lymph node involvement in superficial tumours is not rare. Rectal excision with coloanal anastomosis results in a high cure rate especially for node-positive superficial tumours. This treatment strategy avoids the psychological trauma of colostomy following abdominoperineal resection and the potential risk of undertreatment by local excision.