Femoral shaft fractures in children--a comparison of treatment

Between April 1986 and March 1997, 83 femoral-shaft fractures in children 4-8 years old were treated at Christian Medical College and Hospital, Ludhiana, India. Among 35 patients with a minimum of 12 months follow-up, 14 were treated with Hamilton-Russell (HR) skin traction and 14 with proximal tibial skeletal traction. The group treated with HR traction had a shorter duration of (a) hospital stay (average 16.8 days versus 29.7 days for skeletal traction, p=0.02), (b) time to fracture consolidation (average 8.8 weeks versus 10.8 weeks for skeletal traction, p=0.04), and (c) return to normal activities (average 12.2 weeks versus 17.2 weeks for skeletal traction, p=0.03). At final follow-up (minimum 1 year), there were no significant differences in functional outcomes. Conservative management is still a gold standard for treatment of closed femoral shaft fractures in children 4-8 years of age. There appears to be no advantage to skeletal traction over skin traction in this age group.