CHOP with high dose cyclophosphamide consolidation versus CHOP alone as initial therapy for advanced stage, indolent...

The role of high dose therapy, including autologous stem cell transplantation (ASCT) in indolent non-Hodgkin's lymphomas remains controversial. We evaluated a dose intense regimen of CHOP induction followed by high dose cyclophosphamide consolidation (CHOP-HC) versus CHOP alone in a prospective comparison to assess intensified therapy without ASCT. Twenty-five patients with previously untreated advanced stage indolent NHL were enrolled: follicular lymphoma, grade 1 (11 patients) and grade 2 (8 patients); small lymphocytic lymphoma (5 patients); and lymphoplasmacytic lymphoma (1 patient). All patients were treated as clinically indicated. The median age was 47 years (21-70). There were 15 males, and 10 females. Three patients had intra-abdominal stage II, 2 patients with stage III, and 20 patients with stage IV disease. All patients received induction with CHOP for 4 cycles (weeks 1, 4, 7, 10): cyclophosphamide 750 mg/m2 i.v., doxorubicin 50 mg/m2 i.v., vincristine 1.4 mg/m2 i.v. (2 mg capped dose) and prednisone 100 mg p.o. x 5 days. Following induction, responding patients were given consolidation with either high dose cyclophosphamide @ 3 gm/m2 i.v. for 3 doses with G-CSF (weeks 13, 15, 17) or 2 additional cycles of CHOP (weeks 13, 16), stratified by stage and bulk of disease. The overall response rate to CHOP was 92% (3 CR, 8 PR) and to CHOP-HC was 93% (4 CR, 8 PR). The overall response, complete response and partial response rates were comparable in both arms. Median progression free survival for CHOP was 15.9 and 23.0 months for CHOP-HC. At 74.3 months median follow-up, all patients in the CHOP arm have recurred; 3 patients in the CHOP-HC arm (3 CR) have not recurred. The median overall survival has not been reached (at 5 years, 77% OS for CHOP-HC versus 83% OS for CHOP alone]. Greater hematologic toxicity was observed with CHOP-HC resulting in an increased number of hospitalizations for sepsis. There were no treatment-related deaths. No myelodysplasia or acute leukemia has been seen to date. With no obvious improvement in CR and with greater hematologic toxicity than CHOP, CHOP-HC is not recommended for treatment of indolent non-Hodgkin's lymphomas.