Partial defluoridation of drinking water using fluorapatite precipitation

Ion adsorption and ion exchange are two methods commonly used in small home units to treat drinking water to bring the fluoride concentration to within acceptable limits. However, the necessary flowthrough system is often difficult to arrange where there is no piped supply and gradual exhaustion of the active agent is not easily detected. In an attempt to overcome these problems a defluoridation method based on the precipitation of a sparingly soluble fluoride salt, fluorapatite, has been studied. Samples of simulated high-fluoride drinking waters, approximately 10 ppm F, were saturated with brushite, resulting in a state of supersaturation with respect to fluorapatite. Subsequent seeding with hydroxyapatite caused a lowering of the calcium, phosphate, and fluoride concentrations in solution, indicative of fluorapatite precipitation. Repeating the process had an additive effect. Bone char was a less effective seed than hydroxyapatite with water containing fluoride only, but was a more effective seed with simulated Kenyan borehole water containing additional salts. Sixty-minute brushite saturation and apatite seeding steps were generally more effective than 10-min steps. The results suggest that apatite coprecipitation may be a convenient low-technology way to defluoridate drinking water, although prior testing might be useful to ensure adequate removal of fluoride.