An assessment of the ability of human bone marrow cultures to generate osteoclasts

Several groups have successfully generated osteoclasts in cultures of murine haemopoietic cells. This approach would clearly be useful in the analysis of mechanisms of regulation of human osteoclast formation if analogous results could be obtained in cultures of human bone marrow. This communication describes independent attempts by three groups to generate unequivocally defined osteoclasts from bone marrow obtained from human iliac crest, femoral neck, rib, and from foetuses. The haemopoietic tissue was incubated using techniques described by others for production of osteoclast-like cells, and with variants of this technique using strategies based on our experiences with murine osteoclastogenesis. Haemopoietic cells were incubated with calcium regulating hormones, cytokines, osteoblastic supernatants, and osteoblastic or bone marrow stromal cell layers. Formation of cells capable of excavation of bone slices was rarely seen. Despite the paucity of bone resorbing cells, multinucleate cells (MNCs) developed with similar characteristics to the MNCs that have been interpreted as osteoclast-like in human bone marrow cultures. The MNCs were, however, calcitonin-receptor (CTR) negative, and did not show the typical pattern of reactivity with osteoclast-specific antibodies. They possessed instead an antigenic profile characteristic of macrophage polykaryons. We conclude that the MNCs which consistently generate in human bone marrow cultures do not possess phenotypic characteristics specific for osteoclasts and appear to be macrophage polykaryons. The conditions required for osteoclast generation in cultures of human haemopoietic cells remain to be defined.