Analysis of epithelial and lymphoid phenotypic markers in relation to growth pattern of colorectal adenomas

The relationship of villous to tubular adenomas is poorly understood and often difficult to characterize morphologically. A villous growth pattern in colorectal adenomas has been associated with a higher frequency of high-grade dysplasia. We compared phenotypic markers using immunoperoxidase techniques in paired samples of villous (75% to 100% villous) and pure tubular adenomas matched for size and degree of dysplasia, which were selected by review of 1,000 polyps from our files. The following monoclonal antibodies were used: CAM 5.2 and AE1/AE3 to cytokeratins; B18, D14, B7.1, and B7.8 to four distinct carcinoembryonic antigen epitopes; Leu-M1 and LN3 to HLA-DR antigen; LN2 to invariant chain class II major histocompatibility complex; LN1 and MB2 to B-cell markers; UCHL1 and MT1 to T-cell markers; Leu-7 to natural killer cells; Mac 387 to macrophages; S-100 to Langerhans-type cells; and a polyclonal antibody to secretory component. LN3 reactivity correlated with villous morphology and secretory component correlated with tubular morphology. Combined HLA-DR and secretory component expression discriminated between tubular and villous growth patterns in 12 of 15 pairs of adenomas (P less than .001). LN2 was expressed more frequently than LN3, but did not correlate with growth pattern. Neuroendocrine cells (Leu-7) were more frequent in tubular adenomas. Carcinoembryonic antigen epitopes did not relate to growth pattern. We did not confirm previously reported differences in cytokeratin expression. We concluded that among the markers tested, HLA-DR expression, which may have an immunologic basis, is most characteristic of colorectal adenomas that exhibit a villous growth pattern.