Use of calcium alginate to pack abscess cavities: a controlled clinical trial

Many conventional dressings are painful when removed, and may be detrimental to healing. In a pilot study ten consecutive abscesses, requiring incision and drainage, were packed with a calcium alginate dressing: this was well tolerated, its removal causing minimal pain. No adverse effects were attributable to its use. A controlled trial was therefore carried out to compare calcium alginate with the more traditional saline-soaked gauze for packing abscess cavities, following incision and drainage. Patients were randomized to receive either calcium alginate (16 patients) or gauze dressing (18 patients). At the first dressing change the patient marked on a linear analogue scale the pain experienced; the nurse noted similarly the ease of removal of the dressing. Calcium alginate was significantly less painful to remove after operation (P less than 0.01), and also easier to remove (P less than 0.01) than gauze dressings. If abscess cavities are packed after incision and drainage, calcium alginate appears to be an improvement on conventional dressings.