Role of maternal toxicity in assessing developmental toxicity in animals: a discussion

The belief that any drug or chemical, when administered at a high enough dose, can be expected to produce fetal malformations is not consistent with the facts. However, the stress associated with maternally toxic doses can be expected to result in associated, often transient, fetal abnormalities that may not be the result of deviant organogenesis. Sometimes the toxicity toward the pregnant animal, including her embryos/fetuses since they are hardly in a sanctuary, is severe enough to result in resorption of the embryo or abortion of the fetus. Thus, it is possible that the embryolethality and other indications of developmental toxicity, produced by some drugs and chemicals, may be the result of a mechanism(s) other than selective toxicity toward the embryo. Also, some test materials have been shown to affect maternal homeostasis, thereby disrupting support to the embryo, without causing significant overt toxicity to the embryo or dam; e.g., the endocrine system of the dam is altered. Routine testing has thus far revealed a relatively limited number of true teratogens, although a large number of drugs and chemicals have resulted in fetal effects such as developmental variations when administered at doses that approach lethal levels. Such effects on the fetus should be expected when the maternal animals are stressed by the high dosages usually employed. A better understanding of the etiology and biological relevance of the embryo/fetal deviations often seen in developmental toxicology studies might help to avoid the sometimes unjustified withholding of potentially useful drugs and chemicals from the marketplace.