Reproducibility of an electronic probe in relative attachment level measurements

4 probing designs have been employed to investigate the reproducibility of the Florida Probe. 3 groups (each composed of 10 subjects) were selected for the study: healthy adults, gingivitis subjects, and periodontitis subjects. The 4 probing designs were as follows: (a) the probe tip was left in the sulcus between successive probings; (b) the probe tip was removed from the gingival margin between probings but the next probing followed immediately; (c) successive whole-mouth probings were interrupted by a 5-min interval and a mouthrinse; (d) there was a 4-week interval between each probing. 3 measurements were taken for each design. The main purpose of this study was to identify variance components in the attachment level variation. The maximum probing error standard deviation was found to be around 0.3 mm, which is considerably smaller than that found in most previous studies. The errors associated with the periodontal condition and probing effect were also estimated. The variance components obtained here can be used for determining the sample size in controlled clinical studies.