Bone Remodeling
pH Homeostasis
Skeleton and Calcium Homeostasis
Acid-Base Balance
Respiratory Regulation of Acid-Base Balance
Renal Regulation of Acid-Base Balance
You might also read
Articles linked to this work by shared authors, journal, and citation graph.
Updated: Jul 23, 2026

Analysis of Minerals Produced by hFOB 1.19 and Saos-2 Cells Using Transmission Electron Microscopy with Energy Dispersive X-ray Microanalysis
Published on: June 24, 2018
1Department of Anatomy and Developmental Biology, University College London, Gower Street, London WC1E 6BT, UK. t.arnett@ucl.ac.uk
This study explores how acid-base balance affects bone cell function, focusing on osteoclasts. Researchers found that osteoclasts are most active at a pH of about 6.9 and are inactive above pH 7.3. Even small pH changes can significantly alter resorption rates. Chronic acidosis, from causes like diet or disease, stimulates bone resorption independently of chemical dissolution. The results suggest that acidosis may trigger a biological response in osteoclasts, possibly an evolutionary adaptation to correct systemic acidosis. These findings highlight the importance of pH in bone health and suggest that even mild acidosis could lead to bone loss over time.
Area of Science:
Background:
It was already known that systemic acidosis affects bone mineral directly. However, the specific role of pH in osteoclast activity remained unclear. Earlier studies suggested a physico-chemical dissolution of bone in acidic conditions. This gap motivated a reevaluation of how pH influences osteoclast function. The assumption that all acidosis-induced bone loss is chemical was challenged by recent findings. No prior work had resolved whether osteoclasts themselves respond to pH changes. This uncertainty drove experiments using cultured osteoclasts. The results revealed a direct dependence of resorption on extracellular pH.
Purpose Of The Study:
The aim of this research was to determine how extracellular pH influences osteoclast-mediated bone resorption. The specific problem addressed was whether acidosis stimulates osteoclast activity independently of chemical dissolution. The motivation arose from observations that acidosis leads to bone depletion. The researchers proposed to test if pH directly affects osteoclast function. This question was framed by prior knowledge of systemic acidosis effects. The study aimed to distinguish physico-chemical from biological contributions to resorption. The hypothesis was that acidosis activates osteoclasts directly. This approach allowed a focused analysis of pH-dependent resorption mechanisms.
Main Methods:
The researchers used cultured osteoclasts to examine resorption under different pH conditions. They measured pit formation as an indicator of resorption activity. Extracellular pH was systematically varied to observe its effects. The experiments included both acute and chronic acidosis models. Whole-bone cultures were also tested to assess systemic effects. HCO3- acidosis was applied to simulate chronic conditions. The study compared resorption rates at pH levels from 6.9 to 7.3. These methods allowed a direct assessment of pH-dependent osteoclast function.
Main Results:
The strongest finding was that osteoclasts are inactive at pH levels above 7.3. Maximum resorption occurred at a pH of about 6.9. A pH shift of less than 0.05 units could double or halve pit formation. These results suggest a high sensitivity to pH changes. In whole-bone cultures, chronic HCO3- acidosis stimulated Ca2+ release. The physico-chemical component of resorption was negligible under these conditions. Local acidosis from inflammation or disease also increased resorption. These findings indicate a direct biological response to pH changes.
Conclusions:
The authors propose that acidosis stimulates osteoclasts independently of chemical dissolution. This effect may represent an evolutionary adaptation to correct systemic acidosis. The results suggest that even mild chronic acidosis can cause bone loss over time. The study supports the idea that osteoclasts evolved to release alkaline minerals in acidic conditions. The findings trace to the observed pH-dependent resorption in cultured cells. The researchers suggest that systemic and local acidosis both contribute to bone resorption. These conclusions are based on the direct effects of pH on osteoclast activity. The authors emphasize the need to consider pH in bone health assessments.
Osteoclasts are inactive at pH levels above 7.3 and show maximum stimulation at pH 6.9.
Chronic HCO3- acidosis in whole-bone cultures stimulates Ca2+ release with minimal physico-chemical contribution.
Osteoclasts are highly sensitive to pH changes; shifts of less than 0.05 units can double or halve resorption activity.
Excessive protein intake, acid feeding, prolonged exercise, and aging can cause mild chronic acidosis.
Local acidosis from inflammation or disease increases resorption by directly stimulating osteoclasts.
The researchers propose this is a 'fail-safe' mechanism to release alkaline minerals in systemic acidosis.