The two trace transfer problem re-examined

The classical two trace transfer problem initially discussed by Evett is reconsidered [Evett IW. On Meaningful Questions: A Two-Trace Transfer Problem. Journal of the Forensic Science Society 1987; 27: 375-381]. In this problem we consider the situation where there are two stains of differing types at a crime scene. Evett considered the situation where both are known to be relevant to the offence. It was further assumed that there were exactly two offenders. Reanalysis of this problem suggests that the key consideration is the conditioning on there being exactly two offenders, not that there were two stains. The treatment here leads easily to a generalisation in which stains have differing relevance and there are k offenders.