[Controversies in esophageal cancer surgery]

In esophageal cancer treatment, the choice of treatment modality and the indications and extent of lymph node dissection surgery are controversial. In terms of the biological characteristics, esophageal cancer is more virulent than any other gastrointestinal malignancy. The distribution of lymph node metastases is very wide, extending from the neck to abdominal regions, and the sizes of lymph node metastases are very small. Almost two-thirds of all metastatic lymph nodes showed minute metastases less than 5 mm in diameter. In patients with superficial cancer with only submucosal invasion, lymph nodes metastases were found in both the upper mediastinal and paracardial areas in up to 27% cases. Furthermore, the accuracy of preoperative diagnosis of lymph node metastasis in esophageal cancer is still unsatisfactory. False negative rates in preoperative diagnosis of lymph node metastases are 14% in the neck area, 36% in the mediastinal area, and 34% in the abdominal area. Therefore, in order to cure esophageal cancer by surgery, wide, precise and complete removal of possible metastatic lymph nodes is essential. It is at this time that the quality assurance of surgery is indispensable in reducing morbidity and mortality, and in improving the patient survival. Because both surgery and chemoradiotherapy are local treatments, we must recognize the limitation of these therapeutic modalities. To improve overall survival of esophageal cancer patients, we have to make a more concentrated effort toward the systemic control of this disease.