Related Experiment Video
Updated: Aug 30, 2026

Microbial Control and Monitoring Strategies for Cleanroom Environments and Cellular Therapies
Published on: March 17, 2023
Using medium-fill simulation to establish a benchmark microbiological contamination rate for low-risk-level
Lawrence A Trissel1, Abayomi B Ogundele, Delshalonda S Ingram
1Division of Pharmacy, Box 90, University of Texas M. D. Anderson Cancer Center, 1515 Holcombe Boulevard, Houston, TX 77030, USA.
Abstract:
A benchmark contamination rate for prefilled syringe compounding was determined by using a medium-fill-simulation method. One thousand thirty-five 1-mL tuberculin syringes were aseptically filled with 0.9 mL of sterile soybean-casein digest medium and capped. These syringes were placed into clear nonsterile plastic bags and incubated at 35 degrees C for seven days, then inspected for cloudiness or colony formation indicative of bacterial growth. The operation was performed by two certified pharmacy technicians in an ISO Class 5 vertical-airflow biological safety cabinet in a typical inpatient pharmacy compounding area over two days. The technicians wore protective garments and gloves and followed standard procedures of preparing sterile injections. The adequacy of the methodology was verified by using four syringes that contained deliberately contaminated medium and incubating them along with 15 aseptically prepared syringes at 35 degrees C for seven days. Colony formation in the four syringes containing contaminated medium was directly observed and differentiated from the control syringes, which confirms the validity of the method. No bacterial growth was detected in any of the 1035 medium-filled syringes studied. Therefore, the contamination rate for aseptic compounding operation was less than 0.1%. Medium-fill-simulation testing of 1035 prefilled tuberculin syringes yielded no contamination. A contamination rate of less than 0.1% should be achievable and expected for this type of low-risk pharmacy preparation after pharmacies validate their own compounding operation.
Insights
A benchmark study found that aseptic compounding of prefilled syringes using a medium-fill simulation had a contamination rate below 0.1%. This indicates that sterile injection preparations can achieve low contamination rates when pharmacies validate their processes.
Area of Science:
- Pharmaceutical Compounding
- Sterile Preparation Validation
- Microbial Contamination Control
Background:
- Establishing benchmark contamination rates is crucial for ensuring the safety of sterile pharmaceutical preparations.
- Prefilled syringes are commonly used, necessitating reliable aseptic compounding techniques.
- Current methods for assessing contamination in compounding require validation.
Purpose of the Study:
- To determine a benchmark contamination rate for aseptic compounding of prefilled syringes.
- To validate a medium-fill simulation method for detecting microbial contamination.
- To establish an expected contamination rate for low-risk pharmacy preparations.
Main Methods:
- Aseptic filling of 1035 sterile 1-mL tuberculin syringes with soybean-casein digest medium.
- Incubation of filled syringes at 35°C for seven days to detect bacterial growth.
- Validation of the methodology using deliberately contaminated syringes to confirm detection accuracy.
Main Results:
- No bacterial growth was detected in any of the 1035 aseptically filled medium-fill syringes.
- The medium-fill simulation method successfully differentiated between contaminated and uncontaminated syringes.
- The contamination rate for the aseptic compounding operation was determined to be less than 0.1%.
Conclusions:
- A contamination rate below 0.1% is achievable and expected for low-risk prefilled syringe compounding.
- The medium-fill simulation is a valid method for assessing aseptic compounding processes.
- Pharmacies should validate their compounding operations to ensure low contamination rates.
Related Concept Videos
Microbial Growth Measurement: Direct Methods
Scale-Up Processes

