Related Experiment Videos
Notation to symbol: Development in children's understanding of print
Ellen Bialystok1, Michelle M Martin
1Department of Psychology, York University, 4700 Keele Street, Toronto, Ont., Canada M3J 1P3. ellenb@yorku.ca
Journal of Experimental Child Psychology
|October 16, 2003
Summary
Children often misunderstand how print carries meaning. Even when shown a word card, young children incorrectly assume the word changes to match the nearest picture, indicating a developmental gap in understanding symbolic representation.
Area of Science:
- Cognitive Development
- Developmental Psychology
- Early Literacy
Background:
- Understanding the symbolic nature of print is crucial for early reading acquisition.
- Children's developing cognitive abilities influence their interpretation of written language.
Purpose of the Study:
- To investigate children's grasp of the symbolic nature of print using the moving word task.
- To examine factors influencing children's understanding, including cognitive abilities and task variations.
Main Methods:
- Three studies employed the moving word task, presenting a word card with two pictures.
- Children were asked to identify the word, with the card's position manipulated relative to the pictures.
- Variations included examining the effect of the move, print source, card visibility, and the role of the matching picture.
Main Results:
- Children consistently identified the word based on the closest picture, regardless of the actual word presented.
- This pattern persisted across different task variations, indicating a common misconception.
- Executive functions, such as representation and inhibition, were found to be significant in children's responses.
Conclusions:
- Young children often fail to understand that print has a stable, symbolic meaning independent of its spatial context.
- This suggests a fundamental misconception about how print signifies meaning prior to developing reading skills.
- Executive processes play a key role in overcoming this developmental challenge.