Aromaticity of benzene in the facial coordination mode: a structural and theoretical study

The effects of facial coordination of benzene to a trinuclear transition-metal cluster have been studied by structure correlation and DFT calculational methods. Data taken from the X-ray crystal structures of twelve complexes [(eta-C(5)H(4)R")Co(3)(micro(3)-eta(2):eta(2):eta(2)-C(6)H(4)RR')] 1 b-1 m were analyzed by using standard statistical methods. The prototypal facial arene ligand is considerably expanded with respect to free benzene and shows a small but highly significant Kekulè distortion (d(CC)=1.42, 1.45 A). DFT MO calculations were carried out on the model complexes [(eta-C(5)H(5))M(3)(micro-eta(2):eta(2):eta(2)-C(6)H(6))] 1 a (M=Co), 2 (M=Rh), and 3 (M=Ir). Ring currents in the facial benzene and apical cyclopentadienyl ligands have been assessed by nucleus independent chemical shift (NICS) calculations. Compared to the free ligand (with the optimized D(6h) structure as well as with D(3h) and a C(3v) geometries similar to that in the prototypal facial arene), facial benzene exhibits somewhat reduced but still substantial cyclic electron delocalization (CED). The calculated order of CED is benzene approximately [(CO)(3)Cr(eta-C(6)H(6))] 4 > 1 > 2 > 3.