Effects of stress and relaxation on capsaicin-induced pain

A sizable body of research has been devoted to understanding the relationship between pain sensitivity and the psychological state of the individual. Considerable disagreement as to the direction of the association still exists. This study examines the effects of 2 experimental manipulations, cognitive/emotional stress and relaxation, on capsaicin-induced pain. Subjects were pretrained in relaxation and then randomized to experimental stress produced by a 20-minute Stroop test, relaxation (tape), or a control condition (neutral video), followed by a capsaicin injection in the forearm. Cardiovascular measures were taken at regular intervals, and cortisol, norepinephrine (NE), and self-reports of arousal (relaxation index) were taken immediately before and after the experimental task. The manipulation significantly interacted with sex to predict capsaicin-induced maximum pain. Women in the stress condition reported greater pain than both men in the stress condition and women in the relaxation condition. Pain was correlated negatively with task-induced changes in NE and cortisol and positively with self-reported arousal (decreased relaxation). However, separate analyses showed that some physiologic indexes of heightened arousal (increased blood pressure and NE) predicted lower pain only in men, whereas subjective increases in arousal predicted higher pain only in women. Multiple hierarchical regression analyses confirmed that physiologic and self-reported arousal predicted pain independently and in opposite directions, and a model including both accounted for 56% of the overall variance. These findings suggest that a unidimensional model of arousal may be insufficient to explain the effects of stress on pain and that these effects operate differently in men and women.