[Heart valve substitution: the effect of preoperative findings on long-term outcome]

In a retrospective analysis of 653 consecutive patients who underwent heart valve replacement by one single type of mechanical prosthesis (St. Jude Medical) at three Swiss university medical centers (Basel, Bern, Lausanne), the outcome was judged on the basis of preoperative variables. These variables should facilitate the timing of heart valve replacement.

Preoperative evaluation includes NYHA classification of symptoms, chest X-ray, ECG, and LVEF on angiography. Postoperative outcome was assessed clinically at yearly intervals by NYHA classification, documentation of complications and mortality.

Five-year-survival rates were 96 and 88%, and complication-free rates were 82 and 76% respectively in patients after isolated aortic and mitral valve replacement. An unsatisfactory outcome with death or persistent severe symptoms was more frequent when preoperative symptoms at rest and atrial fibrillation were present.

Heart valve replacement should not be postponed until severe symptoms and functional impairment occur. Clinical criteria are at least as important for the timing of operation as the findings of more complex investigations.