Divergent effects of thyroid HLA-antigens on T and natural killer (NK) cell cytotoxicity

We have used non-autoimmune non-neoplastic human thyroid cells to explore the role of surface class I and DR antigens on these cells' sensitivity towards T and Natural Killer (NK) cell cytotoxicity. Non-treated thyrocytes expressed class I but no DR antigens. Following incubation with gamma-interferon (gamma-IFN) class I antigens were markedly elevated and DR expression was induced. Whereas non-treated thyrocytes were minimally lysed by sensitized T cells, they served as appropriate targets for NK cells. Following incubation with gamma-IFN, the thyroid cells became highly sensitive to T cell lysis, with no significant reduction in their vulnerability to NK cell killing. The addition of monoclonal anti class I or DR antigens, or brief acid treatment which specifically eliminates class I molecules, inhibited T cell cytotoxicity but enhanced the sensitivity to lysis by NK cells. Thus, the presence of HLA antigens on the same thyroid cells have an opposite effect on two major cytotoxi mechanisms. Our findings are relevant within the context of recent suggestions of intervening with target HLA antigens for the management of autoimmune and malignant diseases.