Re-excisions of scar in primary cutaneous melanoma: a histopathological study

In many centres the wide excision and split-skin grafting remains the standard therapy for primary cutaneous melanoma. One-hundred and thirty-seven primary cutaneous melanomas were seen in our department during a 3-year period; 25 patients were subsequently subjected to re-excision of scar following the initial excision biopsy. Lymphatic permeation, field change in the epidermal melanocytes and micrometastases were sought in the re-excision specimens in order to examine the pathological basis for this therapy. Two of the 25 primary melanomas included in this study were known to have been incompletely excised at the time of initial biopsy and both re-excision specimens included a few nests of atypical melanocytes adjacent to one edge of the biopsy wound. Examination of the re-excision specimens failed to demonstrate evidence of direct lymphatic permeation by melanoma, or of a field change in the epidermal melanocytes adjacent to the melanomas, although five specimens from sun-exposed sites showed slight melanocyte atypia. One re-excision specimen did include a single small group of melanocytes, less than 120 microns in size, in the dermis within 2 mm of the initial excision biopsy site of a melanoma 8.4 mm in thickness. These results support the view that more extensive local therapy than complete excision of primary cutaneous melanoma with a narrow margin of adjacent normal skin, is unlikely to benefit the patient.