Related Experiment Video
Updated: Aug 21, 2026

Evaluation of Host-Pathogen Responses and Vaccine Efficacy in Mice
Published on: February 22, 2019
Risk factors for acellular and whole-cell pertussis vaccine failure in Senegalese children
Karine Lacombe1, Abdoulaye Yam, Kirsten Simondon
1Epidemiology and Prevention Research Unit, Institut de Recherche pour le Développement, IRD Montpellier France and Dakar, Sénégal, 911 Avenue Agropolis, 34394 Montpellier, France. francois.simondon@mpl.ird.fr
Insights
Environmental factors like exposure and birth rank significantly impact pertussis vaccine failure. Understanding these risks is crucial for improving pertussis (whooping cough) vaccination strategies.
Area of Science:
- * Epidemiology
- * Vaccinology
- * Infectious Disease Control
Background:
- * The Senegal Pertussis Trial (1990-1994) indicated higher pertussis vaccine failure rates with acellular pertussis vaccine compared to whole-cell vaccine.
- * Previous analyses did not extensively explore risk factors for pertussis vaccine failure related to exposure and child susceptibility.
Purpose of the Study:
- * To investigate risk factors for pertussis vaccine failure, considering exposure and susceptibility, independent of vaccine type.
- * To analyze how factors like birth rank, weaning time, and exposure degree influence vaccine effectiveness.
Main Methods:
- * Analysis of data from the Senegal Pertussis Trial involving 4189 children.
- * Statistical assessment of pertussis occurrence in 346 vaccinated children to identify independent risk factors.
Main Results:
- * Three key factors — degree of exposure, birth rank, and time since weaning — were associated with pertussis vaccine failure, irrespective of vaccine type.
- * In the whole-cell vaccine group, higher birth rank and non-stunted status increased failure risk.
- * In the acellular vaccine group, older age at exposure (post-18 months) and sharing a hut with an infected individual elevated failure risk.
Conclusions:
- * Environmental and individual factors significantly influence the success of pertussis vaccination.
- * While environmental factors are identified, they do not fully explain the observed shorter duration of protection with acellular pertussis vaccine compared to whole-cell vaccine.
- * The intrinsic nature of the acellular vaccine may contribute to its differing duration of protection.
Abstract:
Although use of acellular pertussis vaccine was associated with a higher rate of vaccine failure than that of whole-cell vaccine in the Senegal Pertussis Trial conducted in 1990-1994 on 4189 children, risk factors for vaccine failure regarding exposure and susceptibility to pertussis have not been studied so far. Pertussis occurred in 346 vaccinated children. Three factors were found to be associated with vaccine failure, independently of the vaccine type, namely the degree of exposure, birth rank, and time since weaning. In the whole-cell vaccine group, the risk of failure increased with birth rank [RR = 2.95 (1.51-5.75)] and was higher in non stunted children [RR = 1.43 (1.05-1.94)]. In the acellular vaccine group, the risk of failure increased with age at exposure to B. pertussis [RR = 2.24 (1.21-4.12) after 18 months of age] and the degree of exposure [RR = 2.14 (1.17-3.93) when the child shared the hut of an index case]. These results highlight the influence of environmental factors on the success of pertussis vaccination. However, they do not explain the shorter duration of protection provided by the acellular vaccine compared to the whole-cell vaccine which persist after controlling and thus might be related to the nature of the vaccine.
Related Concept Videos
Respiratory Syncytial Virus Disease
Vaccinations
Smallpox
Poliomyelitis
Bacterial Meningitis II: Pathophysiology
Vaccines

