Cancer cells as targets for lentivirus-mediated gene transfer and gene therapy

Lentiviruses have been used as gene transfer vectors for almost 10 years and their utility has been demonstrated in a variety of different applications. However, their value in cancer gene therapy has not been studied thoroughly. Here we show that VSV-G pseudotyped HIV-1-based lentiviruses are efficient vectors for human tumor cells in vitro and in vivo. Lentiviral gene transfer efficiency was demonstrated by transducing 42 different cell lines, representing 10 different human tumor types. It was shown that most of the cell lines were good or excellent targets for lentiviral transduction, allowing 50-95% gene transfer efficiency. These results were comparable to those obtained with an E1/E3 deleted, serotype 5 adenovirus vector. Analysis of lentivirus vector structure revealed that virus particles devoid of HIV-1 accessory proteins appeared to be more efficient, but the presence of enhancing elements cPPT and WPRE did not play a major role in transduction efficiency to four different human tumor cell lines. However, their effect on the gene expression level in these cells was apparent. To examine the impact of lentiviral gene expression level on suicide gene therapy approach, human osteosarcoma cells were transduced with lentivirus- or adenovirus vectors carrying the fusion gene HSV-TK-GFP and exposed to ganciclovir. Cell viability analysis after the treatment revealed that both vector types induced similar level of cytotoxicity, suggesting that lentiviral expression of a suicide gene is adequate for tumor cell destruction. Finally, in vivo transduction studies with subcutaneous tumors showed that lentivirus vectors can yield similar gene transfer efficiency than adenovirus vector, despite three orders of magnitude lower titer of the lentiviral preparation. In conclusion, these data show that lentiviruses are efficient gene transfer vehicles for human tumor cells and justify their use in further preclinical cancer gene therapy studies.