Biomechanical properties of heat-treated bone grafts

A possible critical complication associated with banking bone is human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection. Recently, since the report of HIV infection in bone allografts from an HIV-seronegative donor, a more reliable method of sterilization for preserved bone graft has become necessary. Heat treatment of banking bone is one of the simple sterilization methods. This method is especially safe and practical for the prevention of HIV infection.

We previously reported a biological study on heat-treated bone graft. In that study, we showed that revascularization and new bone formation of bone graft after heat treatment at 60 degrees C was nearly the same as that of non-heat-treated bone graft, while at 100 degrees C, revascularization and new bone formation showed a significant delay. This time, we examined the change of mechanical strength of heat-treated bone grafts after transplantation in an experiment. To eliminate the problem of antigenicity of grafted bone, we used autografts, not allografts. Two types of heat-treated autografts were employed: heat-treated at 60 degrees C for 30 min and heat-treated at 100 degrees C for 5 min; as a control, fresh autografts were replaced in the left femur of rabbits. A strength test was performed for both the transplanted bone and the untreated intact right femur with time after transplantation. The strength test consisted of a compression test and torsional test, and the strength was compared between transplanted bone and the untreated intact right femur.

In the compression test, the grafts heat-treated at 60 degrees C showed a strength ratio before transplantation of 97.3%. The strength ratio decreased to 63.5% at 18 weeks after transplantation. Then the strength ratio increased and recovered to 94.5% at 48 weeks after transplantation. However, the grafts heat-treated at 100 degrees C showed unsatisfactory mechanical strength, at 48 weeks the strength ratio was 60.1%, which was significantly lower compared with controls. In the torsional test, the grafts heat-treated at 60 degrees C showed almost the same strength observed in the compression test. However, the grafts heat-treated at 100 degrees C showed unsatisfactory mechanical strength: at 48 weeks, the strength ratio was 57.3%.

Therefore, heat treatment at 60 degrees C is a useful sterilization method, not only in biological but also mechanical terms.