Positive microscopic margins alter outcome in lymph node-negative cholangiocarcinoma when resection is combined with
David E Stein1, Dwight E Heron, Ernest L Rosato
1Department of Surgery, Jefferson Medical College of Thomas Jefferson University, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA.
Purpose:
The purpose of this study was to evaluate the prognostic significance of positive microscopic margins in hilar cholangiocarcinoma in patients treated with resection and adjuvant radiotherapy.
Materials And Methods:
Between January 1983 and December 1997, 65 patients were definitively diagnosed with hilar cholangiocarcinoma and treated at our institution. Twenty-eight patients underwent curative resection. Of these patients, 23 received adjuvant radiotherapy with an average dose of 53 Gy (both external beam radiotherapy and low-dose rate brachytherapy). Portals included the preoperative primary tumor bed site with a 3- to 5-cm margin, the porta hepatis, and celiac lymph nodes. The patients with lymph node-negative pathologic specimens were reviewed, and an analysis of microscopic margins and subsequent impact on survival was determined with the Kaplan-Meier method and Wilcoxon test.
Results:
There were 16 patients who met inclusion criteria. There was no perioperative mortality. Seven patients had negative margins and 9 patients had positive microscopic margins. Median follow up was 55 months, and median survival was 24.5 months for the entire group. Median and 5-year survival were 21.5 months and 18.4% in the margin-negative group and 26 months and 15% in patients with positive margins (P = 0.45). These survival differences were not statistically significant.
Discussion:
Positive microscopic margins in lymph node-negative, resected hilar cholangiocarcinoma may not represent a negative prognostic factor when resection is combined with postoperative radiotherapy in this cohort. Further prospective, randomized studies are required to fully elucidate the benefits of adjuvant radiotherapy.