Inflammatory lesions in the gingiva following resective/non-resective periodontal therapy

Findings from previous experiments have revealed that inflammatory cell infiltrates may remain in the gingiva following clinically successful non-surgical periodontal therapy.

To investigate the presence of inflammatory lesions in the gingiva following a periodontal treatment procedure that included either soft-tissue resection [gingivectomy (GV)] or non-resective open-flap debridement (OFD).

Fifteen patients with advanced generalized chronic periodontitis were recruited. Following oral hygiene instruction and supragingival debridement, one tooth site in each quadrant (non-molar, probing pocket depth>5 mm, bleeding on probing(+) and >50% bone loss) was selected and a soft-tissue biopsy was obtained and prepared for immunohistochemical analysis. Using a split-mouth design, two quadrants were randomly selected for periodontal therapy including GV, while the two remaining quadrants were exposed to non-resective OFD procedure. Six months after completion of surgical treatment, a new set of biopsies was obtained from GV and OFD sites.

The inflammatory lesions residing in the gingival biopsies obtained prior to surgical therapy were 1.33-1.41 mm(2) large and contained similar proportions of CD19(+)- (B-cells, 15%), CD3(+)- (T-cells, 7%) and elastase(+)- (polymorphonuclear cells, 2%) cells in the two treatment groups. The corresponding lesions identified in the soft-tissue specimens obtained after 6 months of healing were twice as large at OFD as at GV sites (0.19 versus 0.08 mm(2), p=0.002). The densities of CD19(+)- and elastase(+)-cells in these lesions were significantly greater at OFD than at GV sites.

The findings of the present study indicate that surgical therapy including soft-tissue resection results in regenerated gingival units that contain smaller lesions with lower densities of immunocompetent cells when compared with the lesions remaining in sites treated by non-resective means.