Sequential comparison of low dose rate and hyperfractionated high dose rate endobronchial radiation for malignant...

A pilot trial (S2) was conducted at the University of Wisconsin to determine the feasibility, efficacy, and toxicity of hyperfractionated high dose rate endobronchial radiation. To avoid multiple bronchoscopies, an optimized hyperfractionated schema was derived from the linear-quadratic model. Utilizing a single bronchoscopy, 31 patients with malignant airway occlusion received 4 Gy x 4 fractions over 2 days at 2 cm from source center using a high dose rate remote afterloader. Response and morbidity were compared to a previous trial (S1) in which 66 patients were treated with conventional low dose rate endobronchial radiation. Response was assessed by change in performance status, symptom resolution, percent of lifetime rendered symptom-free or improved, and radiographic reaeration. These parameters were highly comparable between the two groups. The mean ECOG performance status improved from 2.2 to 1.8 for S1 and 2.1 to 1.6 for S2; symptom improvement or resolution was noted in 78% for S1 and 79% for S2; lifetime rendered symptom-free or improved was 54% for S1 and 57% for S2; and the overall radiographic response rate was 78% for S1 and 85% for S2. The overall incidence of fistulae was 7/101. We conclude that endobronchial radiation is an effective and safe modality for palliation, and hyperfractionated high dose rate endobronchial radiation achieves responses similar to low dose rate endobronchial radiation with a similar complication rate.