Proposal for a histological scoring and grading system for non-alcoholic fatty liver disease

The spectrum of histopathological features in non-alcoholic fatty liver disease (NAFLD) has been well described. At least two scoring systems have been established. We propose here a system in which numerical scores are obtained using the different features.

Twenty-five cases of well-defined NAFLD were identified. Two pathologists blinded to identifiers and clinical data independently scored the liver biopsies twice for portal fibrosis (PF: 0-6), lobular inflammation and necrosis (LIN: 0-3), Mallory bodies (MB: 0-3), hepatocyte ballooning (HB: 0-3), perisinusoidal fibrosis (PSF: 0-3) and fatty change (FC: 1-4). The kappa statistic tested observer concordance. Non-parametric measures of correlation and hierarchical cluster analysis were used to elaborate a grading system.

A broad spectrum of NAFLD was observed. Intra- and interobserver concordance was satisfactory. An activity score was created (AS: 0-12) as the sum of LIN, MB, HB and PSF, but not FC. A system for severity of NAFLD was developed: Grade 1 (PF: 0-2 and AS: 0-4), Grade 2 (PF: 3 or AS: 5-7) and Grade 3 (PF: 4-6 or AS: 8-12). Diabetes, elevated alkaline phosphatase and decreased platelets were associated with advanced grade.

This simple, reproducible NAFLD score produces a three-tier severity grade. This numerical system may prove useful in assessing disease severity and interval changes.