Related Experiment Video
Updated: Aug 18, 2026
Translational Brain Mapping at the University of Rochester Medical Center: Preserving the Mind Through Personalized Brain Mapping
Published on: August 12, 2019
Localization and William Macewen's early brain surgery Part II: The cases
1School of Psychology, Deakin University Australia. malcolm.macmillan@deakin.edu.au
Abstract:
This paper contains Part II of an evaluation of the claims made for the priority of Macewen's pre-1884 brain surgery over that of Bennett and Godlee. Although the primary sources--Macewen's Private Journals and the Ward Records of the Glasgow Royal Infirmary--confirm that the operations were carried out when Macewen said they were, problems with the sources make it difficult to evaluate the extent to which he actually used knowledge of localization bearing on the claim for his priority evaluated. Part II concludes with citations from archival correspondence and the contemporary and near contemporary medical press confirming Macewen's priority.
Insights
This study confirms William Macewen performed pre-1884 brain surgery as claimed, establishing his priority over Bennett and Godlee. Archival evidence supports Macewen
Area of Science:
- Neurology
- Medical History
- Surgical Innovation
Background:
- Evaluating the historical claims for William Macewen's pioneering brain surgery.
- Assessing the priority of Macewen's pre-1884 procedures compared to Bennett and Godlee.
Discussion:
- Primary sources (Macewen's Journals, Glasgow Royal Infirmary records) verify operation dates.
- Challenges exist in fully assessing Macewen's use of localization knowledge for his priority claim.
- Archival correspondence and contemporary medical press support Macewen's priority.
Key Insights:
- Macewen's pre-1884 brain surgeries are historically validated.
- Confirmation of Macewen's priority in early neurosurgery.
- Evidence supports Macewen's surgical precedence over contemporaries.
Outlook:
- Further research into the extent of localization knowledge application in early neurosurgery.
- Continued historical analysis of surgical priority claims.
- Understanding the evolution of brain surgery techniques and their attribution.
