Comparative assessment of the functional p53 status in glioma cells

p53 is the most frequently mutated gene in human cancers and its functional integrity is an important predictor of treatment response and clinical outcome. The majority of mutations found in different types of cancer cluster within the DNA binding domain encoded by exons 5-8. In clinical specimens the functional status of p53 is, therefore, often evaluated by direct mutation analysis of exons 5-8 or indirectly by immunostaining and evaluation of the subcellular localization pattern or protein accumulation.

In a panel of glioma cell lines, the status of the P53 gene was analyzed by temperature gradient gel electrophoresis (TGGE) of exons 5-8 and direct sequencing of all p53 exons. The nuclear accumulation of p53 in unstressed cells was assessed by immunostaining. These data were correlated with stress induction of the p53 protein, nuclear translocation and a direct determination of the transcriptional activity of endogenous p53 protein and induction of p53 target genes.

Our analysis demonstrated that a p53 gene mutation analysis limited to exons 5-8 and analysis of immunostaining patterns can not serve as reliable predictors of functional p53 in tumor cells. Conversely, in some presumably rare cases, the transcriptional activity of p53 may be retained in tumor cells in the presence of a mutation and a pathological immunostaining pattern. In our analysis, the constitutive dephosphorylation at Ser 376 correlated with the nuclear accumulation of p53, but not with the transcriptional activity of the protein. This suggests that constitutive dephosphorylation at Ser376 may be one of the factors determining stabilization of mutant and wild-type p53, which is frequently observed in glial tumors.

The incidence of a dysfunctional p53 protein in gliomas may be higher than expected, based on a single parameter evaluation by mutation analysis of exons 5-8 or assessment of p53 accumulation and subcellular localization by immunostaining.