Comparative efficacy of replicating smallpox vaccine strains in a murine challenge model

There is currently considerable concern about the vulnerability of human populations to biowarfare or bioterrorist attacks with variola virus (VARV). Traditional smallpox vaccines were manufactured using the lymph of ruminants infected with the vaccinia virus (VACV). However, these production methods do not meet current standards for vaccines, especially since the emergence of transmissable spongiform encephalopathies in domesticated ruminants. This study has examined the protective efficacy of the Lister (Elstree) vaccine strain from various sources in a murine lethal challenge model. Considerable variation in efficacy is observed between the Lister material obtained from the American Type Culture Collection (ATCC) and the same strain obtained from vaccine stockpiles. A new, tissue-culture derived Lister vaccine is assessed against a bench-mark of multiple lots from a historical stockpile of the traditional vaccine. Apparent qualitative differences are observed between historical and new vaccines. Statistically significant differences are observed between different batches of the traditional vaccine, and the efficacy of the tissue-culture produced vaccine falls within this range.