Strain variability in Zucker rats affects their response to oral oleoyl-estrone

There is a considerable variability in the responses of Zucker fa/fa rats in metabolic studies, which could not be solely attributed to the leprfa mutation. In order to fathom the extent of this variability, we compared the response to oleoyl-estrone (OE), a powerful lipid-mobilising agent, of two strains of Zucker lean and obese rats: Harlan (H) and Charles River (CR). Rats were given an oral gavage of 10 micromol/day/kg of OE in sunflower oil, and were compared with oil-receiving controls. Body composition, energy and water balances, and plasma parameters were studied after 10 days of treatment. H rats showed a higher water turnover than CR rats; OE treatment reduced water intake, partly compensated by metabolic water, and decreased stool water. H rats accrued more cholesterol than CR animals, which showed higher cholesterolaemia. OE facilitated cholesterol disposal in lean (CR and H) and H obese rats. CR rats had higher body and liver lipids than H animals. No differences in energy balance were found. Insulin decrease following OE treatment was greater in lean CR than in H rats, but this trend was reversed in the obese rats, lacking effective responses to leptin. The red cell glucose compartment was smaller in H than in CR rats; the higher insulin levels in H rats may be partly responsible for that difference. Obese H maintained glycaemia (and liver glycogen) with higher insulin levels than CR animals. The extent to which the leprfa mutation affects the responses of Zucker fa/fa rats could not be singled out unless the metabolic environment of the batch used is known. This variability must be taken into account when developing a metabolic or hormonal study in which this model of obesity is used.