Teachers' perceptions of difficulties in teaching ethics in residencies

In 1989 the authors surveyed faculty who were teaching medical ethics in residencies in order to obtain information concerning the goals, formats, topics, and settings of such teaching, as well as the difficulties encountered. Of 163 teachers contacted, 94 (58%) responded and 63 (39%), representing 50 institutions, reported participation in formal ethics teaching programs for residents. The 63 teachers reported using a variety of formats, including ethics rounds, lectures, and incorporating ethics teaching into weekly case-management conferences. Frequently mentioned goals of ethics teaching included improving the residents' skills in reasoning about ethical decisions and improving the residents' understanding of the language and concepts of ethics. Thirty-four of the 63 teachers (54%) taught ethics in hospital settings exclusively and 21 (33%) taught both in hospitals and in outpatient clinics or offices. The teachers identified a number of barriers encountered in carrying out such teaching, most of which can be grouped in six categories: (1) time constraints due to residents' heavy schedules; (2) attitudes of residents that pose obstacles; (3) logistical problems associated with teaching in the clinical setting; (4) time demands placed on teachers; (5) lack of reinforcement for teaching ethics from other faculty; and (6) shortcomings in the background and training of faculty for teaching ethics in the clinical setting. The authors conclude that difficulties are commonly encountered and discuss ways to overcome the principal barriers to effective teaching of ethics in the residency years.