Degrees and kinds of selection in spontaneous neoplastic transformation: an operational analysis

Spontaneous neoplastic transformation develops within days in the NIH 3T3 line of cells through differential inhibition of their proliferation under contact inhibition. A small fraction of the population continues to multiply after saturation density is reached and is selected to progressively increase saturation density in successive rounds of confluence. The degree of selection at confluence depends on the extent of proliferation of some cells in a heterogeneous population. The development of transformed foci is an extension of the same selective process that increases saturation density. The expression of the foci is enhanced with increases in the saturation density of the surrounding cells. Transformation is also induced by moderately reducing the concentration of calf serum in the medium during low-density passages, which allows selection of cells that require less growth factor. Further stepwise reductions in serum increase the degree of transformation. Contact inhibition and reduction in serum concentration select for the same phenotype of cell that increases saturation density and generates transformed foci. There is mounting evidence that selection is a major factor in the development of common epithelial tumors of humans, but it extends over decades rather than days, and the in vivo microenvironment selects from more stable populations of cells than those in culture. The many progressive levels of increased saturation density and transformed focus formation suggest that a very large number of genes participate in neoplastic development. The operational model of variation and selection presented here may aid in understanding chemical carcinogenesis and cancer recurrence after chemotherapy.