Related Experiment Videos
Cordelia, Lear, and forgiveness.
1Training and Supervising Analyst, Columbia University Center for Psychoanalytic Training and Research, USA. royschafer@mindspring.com
Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association
|July 28, 2005
Summary
Understanding transference in painful interactions reveals that forgiveness may become irrelevant. Unconscious unforgivingness can persist even when higher ego functioning allows for waiving forgiveness.
Area of Science:
- Psychology
- Psychoanalysis
- Literary Analysis
Background:
- Painful human interactions often trigger desires for forgiveness.
- Psychoanalytic patients may find gratification in reenacting painful interactions through transference.
- The achievement of total forgiveness, for self and others, is a complex and debated concept.
Purpose of the Study:
- To explore the complex relationship between painful interactions, transference, and the concept of forgiveness.
- To examine whether forgiveness becomes irrelevant or achievable in light of new psychological insights.
- To analyze the dynamics of forgiveness and unforgivingness through a literary lens, specifically Shakespeare's King Lear.
Main Methods:
- Analysis of transference dynamics in psychoanalytic patients.
- Literary interpretation of Shakespeare's The Tragedy of King Lear, focusing on the Lear-Cordelia relationship.
- Integration of psychoanalytic concepts, particularly unconscious conflict and ego functioning, with literary analysis.
Main Results:
- Insight into transference reveals gratification in reenacting painful interactions, potentially making forgiveness seem irrelevant.
- Cordelia's response to Lear (
- No cause, no cause,
- suggests a complex waiving of forgiveness.
- Unconscious unforgivingness can coexist with conscious, higher-level ego functioning that enables the relinquishing of forgiveness.
Conclusions:
- The process of understanding transference can alter the perceived need for forgiveness.
- Literary works like King Lear offer valuable insights into the psychological complexities of forgiveness and unforgivingness.
- Complete forgiveness may not always be achievable or even the most psychologically adaptive outcome.