Review of guidelines for bone mineral density testing and treatment of osteoporosis

Clinical practice guidelines (CPGs) are systematically developed statements intended to influence the behavior of health care providers and improve patient care. There are many CPGs with recommendations for selection of patients for bone mineral density testing and pharmacologic treatment of osteoporosis. Health care provider adherence rates for these CPGs are low. The multiplicity of osteoporosis CPGs directed to the same health care providers may play a role in their limited utilization in clinical practice. Similarities, differences, and conflicts in osteoporosis CPGs with wide distribution in the United States were examined. The analysis showed similarities as well as substantial variation in the patient populations addressed, inconsistency of some recommendations, differences in clinical risk factors identified, and sometimes limitations in clinical applications. If the number and diversity of osteoporosis CPGs is adversely affecting their use in clinical practice, then collaboration of stakeholder organizations to develop more consistent CPGs, in combination with systems-based approaches for their implementation, may improve patient care and reduce the burden of osteoporotic fractures.