Related Experiment Video
Updated: Aug 15, 2026

An In Vivo Estrogen Deficiency Mouse Model for Screening Exogenous Estrogen Treatments of Cardiovascular Dysfunction After Menopause
Published on: August 13, 2019
Skeletal effects of estrogen are mediated by opposing actions of classical and nonclassical estrogen receptor
Farhan A Syed1, Ulrike I L Mödder, Daniel G Fraser
1Endocrine Research Unit, Mayo Clinic College of Medicine, Rochester, Minnesota 55905, USA.
Unlabelled:
ER alpha acts either through classical (ERE-mediated) or nonclassical (non-ERE) pathways. The generation of mice carrying a mutation that eliminates classical ER alpha signaling presents a unique opportunity to study the relative roles of these pathways in bone. This study defines the skeletal phenotype and responses to ovariectomy and estrogen replacement in these mice.
Introduction:
Estrogen receptor alpha (ER alpha) can act either through classical estrogen response elements (EREs) or through non-ERE (nonclassical) pathways. To unravel these in bone, we crossed mice heterozygous for a knock-in mutation abolishing ERE binding (nonclassical ER alpha knock-in [NERKI]) with heterozygote ER alpha knockout mice and studied the resulting female ER alpha(+/+), ER alpha(+/NERKI), and ER alpha(-/NERKI) mice. The only ER alpha present in ER alpha(-/NERKI) mice is incapable of activating EREs but can signal through nonclassical pathways, whereas ER alpha(+/NERKI) mice may have a less drastic alteration in the balance between classical and nonclassical estrogen signaling pathways.
Materials And Methods:
BMD was measured using DXA and pQCT at 3 months of age (n = 46-48/genotype). The mice were randomly assigned to sham surgery, ovariectomy, ovariectomy + estradiol (0.25 microg/day), or ovariectomy + estradiol (1.0 microg/day; n = 10-12/group) and restudied 60 days later.
Results And Conclusions:
At 3 months of age, both the ER alpha(+/NERKI) and ER alpha(-/NERKI) mice had deficits in cortical, but not in trabecular, bone. Remarkably, changes in cortical bone after ovariectomy and estrogen replacement in ER alpha(-/NERKI) mice were the opposite of those in ER alpha(+/+) mice. Relative to sham mice, ovariectomized ER alpha(-/NERKI) mice gained more bone (not less, as in ER alpha(+/+) mice), and estrogen suppressed this increase (whereas augmenting it in ER alpha(+/+) mice). Estrogen also had opposite effects on bone formation and resorption parameters on endocortical surfaces in ER alpha(-/NERKI) versus ER alpha(+/+) mice. Collectively, these data show that alteration of the balance between classical and nonclassical ER alpha signaling pathways leads to deficits in cortical bone and also represent the first demonstration, in any tissue, that complete loss of classical ERE signaling can lead to paradoxical responses to estrogen. Our findings strongly support the hypothesis that there exists a balance between classical and nonclassical ER alpha signaling pathways, which, when altered, can result in a markedly aberrant response to estrogen.
Insights
Estrogen receptor alpha (ER alpha) signaling in bone has two pathways: classical and nonclassical. Disrupting classical signaling in mice led to paradoxical responses to estrogen, highlighting the importance of balancing these pathways for bone health.
Area of Science:
- Endocrinology
- Bone Biology
- Molecular Signaling
Background:
- Estrogen receptor alpha (ER alpha) mediates its effects through classical estrogen response elements (EREs) or nonclassical pathways.
- Understanding the distinct roles of these ER alpha signaling pathways in bone is crucial for bone health.
- This study investigates the skeletal phenotype and estrogen response in mice with a mutated ER alpha incapable of ERE binding.
Purpose of the Study:
- To define the skeletal phenotype of mice with impaired classical ER alpha signaling.
- To investigate the response to ovariectomy and estrogen replacement in these genetically modified mice.
- To elucidate the relative contributions of classical and nonclassical ER alpha pathways in bone regulation.
Main Methods:
- Generation of mice with a mutation abolishing ERE binding (nonclassical ER alpha knock-in [NERKI]).
- Phenotypic analysis of ER alpha(+/+), ER alpha(+/NERKI), and ER alpha(-/NERKI) female mice.
- Assessment of bone mineral density (BMD) and responses to ovariectomy and estradiol treatment.
Main Results:
- Mice lacking functional classical ER alpha signaling (ER alpha(-/NERKI)) exhibited cortical bone deficits.
- Ovariectomy and estrogen replacement produced opposite effects on cortical bone in ER alpha(-/NERKI) mice compared to wild-type mice.
- Estrogen demonstrated paradoxical effects on bone formation and resorption in the absence of classical ER alpha signaling.
Conclusions:
- Altering the balance between classical and nonclassical ER alpha signaling pathways results in cortical bone deficits.
- Complete loss of classical ER alpha signaling can lead to paradoxical responses to estrogen in bone.
- A balance between classical and nonclassical ER alpha signaling is essential for normal estrogen response in bone.
Related Concept Videos
Transducer Mechanism: Nuclear Receptors
About 48 different soluble family members of nuclear receptors are identified that can be divided into two main classes:
Target Cell Response to Hormones
Notably, the cellular response can be regulated by altering the number of receptors expressed in the cell. For example, prolonged exposure to elevated hormone levels results in a gradual decline or down-regulation in the number of receptors for that specific hormone on the cell surface. Conversely, in response to low hormone levels, cells may use up-regulation, producing an...
Secondary Messengers in Hormone Action
Many hormones bind to transmembrane G protein-coupled receptors that connect to regulatory G proteins. These G proteins can then activate enzymes such as adenylyl cyclase or phospholipase C. Adenylyl cyclase converts ATP to cAMP, activating...
Internal Receptors
Types of Receptors: Internal Receptors
Similar to membrane-bound receptors, the binding of a ligand to the intracellular receptor of causes a conformational change in the...
Chemical Signaling in the Endocrine System
Lipid-soluble hormones, such as steroid hormones, demonstrate an intracellular action. These hormones traverse cell membranes due to their lipid nature. Once inside the target cell, they...

