Analysis of tissue optical coefficients using an approximate equation valid for comparable absorption and scattering

New photosensitizers activated by longer wavelengths than 630 nm light used with Photofrin II are under evaluation by various groups for the treatment of malignancies. Any increase in tumour volume destroyed by these agents as compared to Photofrin II will be partly determined by tissue penetrance at the longer wavelengths. Attenuation coefficients were measured for various tissues at 630 nm and the more penetrative near infrared wavelength of 789 nm. A new model of light propagation in tissue is shown to be accurate for arbitrary ratios of absorption and scattering, by comparison with a rigorous solution to the transport equation. Absorption and transport scattering coefficients of tissues at 630 and 789 nm were obtained by fitting this model to optical attenuation measurements. In vitro tissues included bovine heart, kidney and tongue, pig liver and fat, and chicken muscle; in vivo tissues included Dunning R3327-AT and R3327-H tumours. The penetration depth was found to be 1.35-2.25 times greater at 789 than 630 nm, depending on tissue type. The greatest differences in penetration between the two wavelengths were in the highly pigmented tissues. These substantial increases in penetration in the infrared may be important in future applications of photodynamic therapy.