Related Experiment Videos
How surgeons disclose medical errors to patients: a study using standardized patients
David K Chan1, Thomas H Gallagher, Richard Reznick
1Division of Neurology, Department of Medicine, University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada.
Surgery
|November 18, 2005
Summary
Physicians struggle to disclose medical errors effectively. Surgeons rarely admit fault or apologize, highlighting a need for better communication training to meet patient safety standards.
Area of Science:
- Medical Communication
- Patient Safety
- Surgical Practice
Background:
- Increasing calls for physicians to disclose medical errors to patients.
- Limited understanding of how physicians, especially surgeons, handle error disclosure.
- Surgical errors carry severe consequences, making communication crucial.
Purpose of the Study:
- To explore how surgeons disclose medical errors.
- Utilized standardized patients to simulate error disclosure scenarios.
- Assessed communication elements in error disclosure.
Main Methods:
- Thirty academic surgeons participated.
- Engaged in 60 simulated error disclosure encounters (face-to-face and videoconference).
- Scored encounters using a 5-element communication scale.
Main Results:
- Surgeons excelled at explaining medical facts (3.93-4.20/5).
- Low rates of admitting error (57%), taking responsibility (65%), and apologizing (47%).
- Limited discussion of prevention (8%) or care transfer (20%).
Conclusions:
- Significant gaps exist between surgeon error disclosure practices and patient expectations.
- Current practices fall short of patient safety goals.
- Need for targeted training programs to improve surgeon communication about errors.