Comparative study of different methods for detection of toxic and other enzymatic factors in Vibrio cholerae strains

The purpose of this work was to characterize the toxin profile and the presence of other virulence factors involved in the pathogenesis and biology of 13 V. cholerae O1 (11 clinical cases and 2 waters) and 6 V. cholerae non O1 strains (4 clinical cases and 2 waters) using genetic (PCR), immunological (RPLA), biochemical (NAD degradation, haemolysis, Kanagawa phenomenon, caseinase, lecithinase, mucinase, amylase, esculine hydrolysis) and cell culture (Vero E6, HEp-2) assays. The results indicated a concordance between PCR-RPLA (84%), PCR-NAD (73%) and RPLA-NAD (84%) methods. The sensitivity of RPLA and NAD degradation methods were comparable to PCR in detecting CT in Vibrio cholerae O1 strains. Although NAD degradation method was not exclusively specific for the CT detection, it proved its usefulness in screening certain virulent, CT-negative clones of V. cholerae. The cytotoxic effect on Vero E6 cells, enzyme production (Kanagawa haemolysins, lecithinase, caseinase, esculine hydrolysis) as well as adherence ability on inert substrate proved to be much more constant in V. cholerae non O1 (CT- negative) than in V. cholerae O1 (CT-positive). All V. cholerae non O1 strains isolated in diarrheal cases were Kanagawa positive. This complex of virulence factors detected in V. cholerae non O1 strains could probably contribute during interepidemic periods to human-to-human transmission and to greater resistance as compared to O1 strains in the environment.