Differential diagnosis between dementia and depression: a study of efficiency increment

A battery of neuropsychological tests was examined to establish its value in differentiating mild dementia from depression. The battery was applied to 84 subjects: 31 dementia patients of several etiologies, 31 patients with major depression and 22 volunteers whose age and educational level was similar to that of the patients. The battery consisted of tests for immediate, recent and remote memory, the Mini Mental State examination, a screening test for language disorders, and tests measuring abstraction, calculation, judgement, praxic and gnosic functions. The results showed significant differences among the three groups in all memory tests. Deficits of abstraction, calculation, praxis and language functions were strongly associated with dementia. The epidemiological analysis of efficiency increment, with determination of sensitivity and specificity, showed a highly significant enhancement of efficiency for diagnostic purposes when the results of the tests were combined. These findings suggest that the entire battery of neuropsychological tests should be applied, and their results compared using the efficiency increment procedure, in order to establish a firm differential diagnosis between dementia and depression, and/or to detect the former when it is at a mild early stage.