Root resorption after orthodontic intrusion and extrusion: an intraindividual study

The aim of this investigation was to compare root resorption in the same individual after application of continuous intrusive and extrusive forces. In nine patients (mean age 15.3 years), the maxillary first premolars were randomly intruded or extruded with a continuous force of 100 cN for eight weeks. Eleven maxillary first premolars from six randomly selected orthodontic patients served as controls. Root resorption was determined using scanning electron microscopy. Quantitative assessment of the percentage of resorbed area of the total root surface was performed on composite micrographs. The severity of root resorption was also assessed by visual scoring of the roots. Root resorption mainly occurred at the apical part of the roots in both experimental groups. A significant difference in root resorption was found between the intruded and the control teeth (P = .006) but not between the extruded and the control teeth. However, the mesial and distal root surfaces showed resorption on 5.78 +/- 3.86% of the root surface of the intruded teeth and 1.28 +/- 1.24% of the root surface of the extruded teeth, and this difference was significant (P = .004). In addition, a large individual variation was found. From this study, it can be concluded that intrusion of teeth causes about four times more root resorption than extrusion. Because the amount of root resorption due to intrusion or extrusion in the same patient is correlated, every clinician should be aware that the extrusion of teeth might also cause root resorption in susceptible patients.