Identification of retinoids with nuclear receptor subtype-selective activities

Retinoic acid (RA) and its synthetic analogues, retinoids, have shown promising results in the prevention of epithelial carcinogenesis and in the treatment of acute promyelocytic leukemia and various proliferative skin disorders. Retinoid action on gene regulation is mediated by three distinct nuclear retinoic acid receptor subtypes, RA receptors alpha, beta, and gamma. The existence of multiple RA receptors has raised the possibility that receptor subtype-specific retinoids with reduced side effects can be developed. To analyze the activity of retinoids at the molecular level, we used a receptor activation assay. RA and 22 retinoids were compared on the three receptor subtypes. We found the alpha receptor to be least sensitive to activation by RA and the gamma receptor to be most sensitive. Compared with RA, one of the retinoids showed increased activity for the alpha and beta receptors. Three retinoids revealed no gene activation activity and showed no antagonistic effects when assayed in the presence of RA. Surprisingly, several of the retinoids were efficient activators of the beta and gamma receptors but poor activators or nonactivators of the alpha receptor. Our data demonstrate that the three RA receptor subtypes have differential ligand activation specificities and that the design of receptor subtype-selective retinoids is possible.