Muscle enhancement using closed-loop electrical stimulation: volitional versus induced torque

In cases of partial deficiency of muscle activation capacity, force augmentation can be achieved by hybrid activation, i.e., by combining electrical stimulation (ES) with volitional activation. In this activation modality the shares of the volitional and induced torques within the overall hybrid torque are unknown. The purpose of this study was to suggest a computational approach to parcel out the volitional and stimulation induced components of joint torque generated during combined voluntary and electrical activation of the Tibialis Anterior muscle (TA). For this purpose, isometric contraction of the TA was studied on 5 healthy subjects, using an activation protocol involving ES alone, volitional activation alone and hybrid activation. Ankle torque and TA EMG were measured. A computational algorithm was developed to dissociate the volitional from the overall torque, based on EMG filtering and on pre-measured calibration curves of volitional torque versus EMG. The results indicated that for a certain hybrid torque there is a linear decaying relationship between the induced torque and the volitional torque shares. Moreover, based on a defined enhancement ratio, the results indicate that within the range of stimulation intensities, there exist regions of increased facilitation, in which the stimulation efficiency is higher under combined compared to isolated conditions.