Single appointment insemination for heifers after prostaglandin or progestin synchronization of estrus

Pregnancy rates to a single appointment insemination were compared in seven groups of beef or dairy heifers following estrus synchronization with the prostaglandin F(2a) product, cloprostenol, versus the progestín product, Syncro-Mate-B. For cloprostenol synchronization, two injections of cloprostenol were given 11 d apart, with insemination occurring at 61+/-1 h after the second injection. The Syncro-Mate-B treatment consisted of a norgestomet/estradiol injection and a norgestomet implant on Day 0, followed by insemination at 49+/-1 h after implant removal on Day 9. Treatments were coordinated so all heifers in each group were housed together at the time of and for 48 h before a common insemination time so that the treatment received by individual heifers was not known. Overall pregnancy rates did not differ between treatment groups: 42% for 111 heifers treated with cloprostenol and 38% for 108 heifers treated with Syncro-Mate-B. Four blood samples per heifer taken during each replicate showed that two groups (n = 67) had many noncyclic heifers, while five groups (n = 152) had very few. Differences in pregnancy rates between these categories existed for both estrus synchronization methods, 18 versus 53% for cloprostenol and 21 versus 45% for Syncro-Mate-B. Thus the two methods were equally effective for cyclic heifers and equally ineffective for noncyclic heifers.