Comparative analysis of different scintigraphic approaches to assess pulmonary ventilation

A study was carried out to investigate the predictive value of 81-metastable-krypton (81mKr) distribution, high-size 99-metastable-technetium (99mTc) aerosol deposition and low-size 99mTc aerosol (Technegas) deposition on the pulmonary ventilation evaluated by 133-xenon (133Xe) lung scintigraphy, and to assess the correlation between the 81mKr distribution, the 99mTc aerosols deposition, and the respiratory parameters of patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD). Twenty COPD patients were included. The 81mKr, 133Xe, and 99mTc aerosol lung scintigraphies were successively carried out. The 81mKr distribution and 99mTc deposition were compared to the 133Xe distribution at equilibrium and to the 133Xe clearance. Sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value (PPV), and negative predictive value (NPV) of 81mKr and Technegas lung scintigraphies to detect alterations in ventilation revealed by 133Xe were defined. The 81mKr distribution and 99mTc deposition according to respiratory parameters were described using a principal component analysis. Compared to 133Xe distribution, a significantly higher distribution of 81mKr in the upper parts of the lungs in the more severe patients (p = 0.05), a significantly higher deposition of Technegas in the lower parts of the lungs (p = 0.0008), and a significantly higher deposition in the central parts of the high-size 99mTc aerosol were observed (p = 0.0001). The PPV and the NPV were, respectively, 0.54 and 0.58 for 81mKr and 0.54 and 0.55 for Technegas. There was a significant negative correlation between 81mKr distribution and 133Xe clearance (p = 0.0001) between Technegas deposition and 133Xe clearance (p = 0.0007), and between 99mTc diethylene-triamino-penta-acetate (DTPA) deposition and 133Xe clearance (p = 0.001). Both the 81mKr peripheral distribution and Technegas peripheral deposition correlated negatively with increased obstruction, as measured by forced expiratory volume in 1 sec (FEV1). Peripheral deposition of the high-size 99mTc aerosol deposition correlated with the inspiration/expiration time ratio. In conclusion, 81mKr and 99mTc aerosols' lung scintigraphies do not reflect exactly the pulmonary ventilation as measured by 133Xe scintigraphy.